A recent statement made by a prominent WNBA player has ignited a heated debate surrounding the state of America just before the nation’s annual Independence Day festivities. Natasha Cloud, a talented guard for the Washington Mystics, found herself facing significant backlash after referring to the country as “trash” in a tweet. Her provocative comment resonated with some individuals in the sports world, who cautioned her about the realities experienced in authoritarian regimes.
The controversy stemmed from Cloud’s response to the Supreme Court’s decision to strike down affirmative action. Expressing her frustration, she tweeted, “Our country is trash in so many ways and instead of using our resources to make it better, we continue to oppress marginalized groups that we have targeted since the beginning of times.” Cloud, who identifies as black and gay, further lamented the wasted potential of the United States due to “hateful ideologies,” stating, “We are a hateful disappointment. That’s the truth. We have the potential to be great.”
However, Cloud’s comments were met with swift criticism. Among her detractors was Johnny “Joey” Jones from Fox News, who labeled her a “quintessential Gen Z” with a “million complaints,” despite the fact that she technically belongs to the Millennial generation. Jones, a Marine veteran who lost both legs in Afghanistan, appeared on “Fox & Friends First” to share his perspective. He emphasized that individuals born into the middle class in the US enjoy a lifestyle that can be considered regal in many other parts of the world. He also highlighted the patriotic nature of immigrants who choose to come to America.
Our country is trash in so many ways and instead of using our resources to make it better we continue to oppress Marginalized groups that we have targeted since the beginning of times.
Black/brown communities& LGBTQ+ man we are too powerful to still be attacking issues separate
— Natasha Cloud (@T_Cloud4) June 30, 2023
Cloud, in an effort to provide context, acknowledged her upbringing in a middle-class white family and expressed gratitude for the opportunities her parents worked hard to provide. However, she pointed out that inherent privileges are bestowed upon white Americans simply by virtue of their skin color. According to Cloud, the greatest challenge faced by the nation is encouraging self-centered, ignorant, misinformed, gullible, and hateful individuals to step outside of themselves.
The discussion continued on “Fox & Friends” as host Will Cain expressed his sadness over Cloud’s tweets, highlighting the difficult circumstances faced by people around the world, including within the United States. Co-host Rachel Campos-Duffy chimed in, asserting that Cloud lacked an appreciation for the way Americans live compared to others worldwide. She questioned Cloud’s understanding of why people from all over the globe strive to enter the US despite its imperfections.
Just ask your colleague Brittney Griner how “trash” America is.
Calling America trash huh?
Let me know when your season is over, I’ll buy your ticket and we can go together to counties like China, Russia, IRAN, North Korea, Venezuela, Cuba, & Turkey.
Forget about calling them… https://t.co/A3Kfojx9jQ
— Enes FREEDOM (@EnesFreedom) July 3, 2023
Joining the critics was former basketball player Enes Kanter Freedom, who questioned how Cloud’s teammate Brittney Griner felt about the US after enduring five months of imprisonment in Moscow. Kanter Freedom invited Cloud to witness the realities of countries like China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Venezuela, Cuba, and Turkey, suggesting that America’s flaws pale in comparison.
Cloud defended her viewpoint, citing her extensive travel experiences and emphasizing the privileges she observed in other countries, such as human rights, healthcare, free or assisted schooling, and reduced fears of mass shootings and white supremacists. She further highlighted issues such as maternal mortality rates, police violence, mass incarceration based on race, inadequate minimum wage, and women’s rights. Cloud’s remarks underscored her belief that the United States has significant room for improvement.
The ongoing debate sparked by Cloud’s comment serves as a reminder of the diverse perspectives within society and the importance of engaging in thoughtful discussions about the nation’s challenges and potential. As America celebrated its Independence Day, this controversy shed light on the ongoing dialogue surrounding the country’s progress and the need for continued efforts toward creating a more inclusive and equitable society.