In an unexpected and eerie discovery, beachgoers in Laguna Niguel, California, were stunned when a bizarre-looking sea creature washed ashore. A photo of the ghastly critter quickly made waves on Reddit, where users expressed everything from shock to amusement, sparking viral interest.

Described as a “nautical nightmare,” the pale, slender creature with rows of menacing, sharp teeth evoked comparisons to the sea monsters of ancient mythology. The sight left viewers both online and on the beach unnerved, with one Redditor admitting, “It’s giving me nightmares.” As is typical with anything unusual found in nature, the online community immediately launched into speculation, with some guessing it could be a plesiosaur—the same type of creature as the legendary Loch Ness Monster.

Other Reddit users kept the humor alive, joking that it resembled an “otter with alopecia,” a dry and sarcastic comment typical of the platform’s satirical culture. But while people’s imaginations ran wild, the truth turned out to be far less dramatic.

California wildlife officials quickly stepped in to identify the mysterious creature, confirming that it was the remains of a moray eel—a common predator in tropical and subtropical waters. Known for their sleek bodies and fearsome appearance, moray eels typically dwell in the crevices of coral reefs, waiting to ambush unsuspecting fish. Despite their fearsome looks, morays are not generally a threat to humans, but they will bite if disturbed.

Tim Daly, a spokesperson for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, noted that the washed-up eel appeared “a little bleached out from being dead” but confirmed its identity as one of over 200 species of moray eel. Some of these eels can grow to nearly 12 feet long, making them formidable ocean predators, though the specimen found in Laguna Niguel was far from that size.

What made this situation particularly entertaining, however, was the light-hearted response it generated online. The name “moray” naturally lent itself to parodies of the famous Dean Martin song “That’s Amore,” with clever Reddit users crafting hilarious verses about the toothy predator. “If the moon hits its eyes like a big pizza pie, that’s a moray,” quipped one user, while another chimed in, “When the jaws open wide, and there’s more jaws inside, that’s a moray.” A third added, “If it washes up dead with sharp teeth in its head, that’s a moray.” The comments kept rolling in, demonstrating how humor can often make the creepy seem less threatening.

While moray eels may not be the mythical sea monsters of legend, their fierce appearance and secretive behavior in the wild make them one of the ocean’s most fascinating predators. Thankfully, despite their razor-sharp teeth and intimidating looks, these creatures pose little risk to humans, as long as they are left undisturbed.

The online spectacle surrounding this washed-up moray serves as a reminder of how the internet reacts to the unusual and unexpected, combining curiosity, fear, and humor into a viral moment. As more strange sights continue to wash ashore or surface in nature, you can be sure that the internet will have something clever—and sometimes hilarious—to say.