In a heartbreaking story that reveals just how broken and politicized our justice system has become, a young woman from Colorado is dead—killed by an illegal immigrant in a high-speed crash. But instead of justice, her family received a slap in the face from a Democrat prosecutor more interested in protecting criminals than American lives.
The killer, a 15-year-old illegal alien whose name remains protected by juvenile confidentiality laws, was racing down the road at nearly twice the posted speed limit when he slammed into Kaitlyn Weaver’s car, ending her life in an instant. She was just beginning a promising life of service, known to friends and family as someone who dedicated herself to helping others.
Yet despite the devastating loss, District Attorney Amy Padden—who ran for office with the usual promises of “criminal justice reform”—chose to offer the teen a sweetheart plea deal. The sentence? Not a day in jail. Just two years of probation and some community service.
You read that right. No jail. No real punishment. Just another tragic American life snuffed out while Democrat prosecutors continue treating illegal aliens as victims and Americans as expendable.
Kaitlyn’s father, John Weaver, appeared on Fox & Friends to share the pain his family is enduring—not just from the loss, but from the system’s utter betrayal.
“They said by doing two years’ probation, that’s probably more than the judge would give if he pleaded guilty,” he said, calling out the cowardice. “You don’t have to participate in a bad system. If the judge wanted to sentence him to less, that’s the judge’s issue. But now you’re part of the problem.”
He nailed the reality in one heartbreaking sentence: “We had a collision where the immigration system and the criminal justice system collided, and now my daughter’s dead.”
Arapahoe County Assistant DA Ryan Brackley—perhaps sensing the public backlash—attempted to distance himself from the disgraceful plea deal. He acknowledged Kaitlyn’s death was “the direct result” of a reckless, unlicensed, and illegal teenager behind the wheel at 90 miles per hour. But his statement, while remorseful, didn’t undo the fact that his office let this killer walk free.
Conservatives across the country are sounding the alarm. Influential commentator Libs of TikTok summed up the outrage perfectly on X:
“SAY HER NAME: Kaitlyn Weaver. She was killed in CO by a 15-year-old illegal alien after he plowed into her with a car at over 90mph. Arapahoe District Attorney Amy Padden (D) has decided to give PROBATION and COMMUNITY SERVICE to the illegal without any jail time. An innocent American is dead while her killer walks free. INSANE.”
SAY HER NAME: Kaitlyn Weaver
She was kiIIed in CO by a 15-year-old illegal alien after he plowed into her with a car at over 90mph.
Arapahoe District Attorney Amy Padden (D) has decided to give PROBATION and COMMUNITY SERVICE to the illegal without any jail time.
An innocent… pic.twitter.com/BWiCPoLlZ7
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) May 14, 2025
Americans are fed up with watching liberal prosecutors side with criminals—especially illegal immigrants—over their own citizens. As one commenter put it, “Kaitlyn would still be alive if Democrat politicians didn’t have such contempt for the American people.”
This case is not an anomaly. It’s a symptom of a much larger disease infecting our justice system: soft-on-crime, pro-illegal policies that are costing innocent lives. Kaitlyn Weaver deserved justice. Her family deserved peace. Instead, they got politics. And an American family is left to grieve while their daughter’s killer walks free.